User blog:TheAverageDimentio/Pure Good Removal - Shadow Joe from Character What

Welp... someone had to do it. Let's face it, nobody cares about or hardly likes Shadow Joe or Shadow Aaron. Shadow Aaron is probably the most disliked page on the Villains Fanon Wiki and I am pretty sure nobody even cares about Shadow Joe. I certainly hate the fact that I have to share a first name with him... but anyway... Shadow Aaron was removed from the CM/PE category on the Villains Fanon Wiki due to hardly standing out to other villains he crossed over with.

Shadow Joe, in a way, hardly stands out as well, and I am sure he will probably end up having a similar fate to Shadow Aaron, but unlike Shadow Aaron (who failed to get the award of becoming one of the most evil villains out there), Shadow Joe doesn't deserve a reward of being one of the best heroes out there.

I am sure I have a bunch of good reasons why this horribly written hero shouldn't be purely good or pure of heart or whatever you call it. Shall we get right into it?

Also, this is the first PG Removal Proposal on this wiki it seems... yeah.

Who is the candidate?
Shadow Joe is the protagonist of Character What, a crossover series... that is all you need to know about him.

Why He Doesn't Qualify
He seems to be a generic hero; he just simply protects people and fights evil, which is well... NOT NEW AT ALL. It is hardly even presented in a new way. His goal isn't really new either, he just wants to simply save the world from evil. Yeah... that doesn't really stand out.

There is also the fact that some of the heroes that the guy has crossed over with are a little more heroic than this guy; especially one particular. He just wants to simply save the world from evil or whatever, while some of the heroes he has crossed over with have LITERALLY saved the entire world/universe/multiverse. One of those heroes is Iron Man; while I am not sure which version of Iron Man this guy crossover with, but consider the fact that Iron Man literally saved the entire universe from Thanos destroying it in the MCU. There is a MASSIVE difference between saving the world from being taken over and saving the universe from destruction.

He pretty much has the exact same flaw as Shadow Aaron just... somewhat opposite; he has crossed over with heroes FAR BETTER than him. Heck, Iron Man isn't even a purely good hero, yet he accomplished something far greater than Shadow Joe. Nothing he does really will stand out compared to him. Now, I guess he could possibly be Pure Good even with that reason, but still.

He also does seem to be somewhat arrogant, given a few of the images I have seen with this guy, so that could also be considered.

Final Verdict
Yeah... cut. I would be a little surprised if he ended up getting approved instead because he certainly doesn't deserve it. But what do you guys think? Cut or keep?